Hey fellow green living enthusiasts! 
I’ve been diving deep into the world of eco-friendly furniture makeovers and recently experimented with chalk paint for the first time. I used Annie Sloan’s Chalk Paint on an old wooden dresser, and I was blown by how easy it was to apply and the matte finish it gave. But, as someone who’s always on the lookout for the most sustainable options, I’m curious about how it stacks up against other natural paints.
Previously, I’ve tried BioShield’s Clay Paint and Eco Paints’ Milk Paint, both of which have their unique benefits. The clay paint was fantastic for walls, offering a breathable surface that’s perfect for older homes. Milk paint, on the other hand, gave me that antique, chippy look I was going for on a vintage chair. But when it comes to furniture, chalk paint seems to be a game-changer with its no-prep, no-sand approach. However, I’m pondering over the environmental impact of the additives in chalk paint versus the more straightforward ingredients in clay and milk paints.
So, here’s where I need your insights! Have you used chalk paint for your furniture projects? How do you think it compares to other eco-friendly paints in terms of durability, finish, and environmental footprint? Also, any tips on sealing chalk-painted furniture without compromising its eco-credentials? Let’s share our experiences and help each other make more informed choices for our planet-friendly projects!
I’ve been using Annie Sloan’s Chalk Paint for a few years now, and I absolutely love it for furniture makeovers. The no-prep aspect is a huge time-saver, and the matte finish is exactly what I’m after for a vintage look. However, I do wonder about the environmental impact of the additives used to achieve that smooth application and durability. Compared to BioShield’s Clay Paint, which I’ve used on walls, chalk paint seems less ‘natural’ due to these additives. But for furniture, the ease of use and finish are hard to beat.
3 Likes
I’m a big fan of Eco Paints’ Milk Paint for that authentic antique look. It’s true that it requires a bit more prep work, but the finish is unparalleled. I haven’t tried chalk paint yet, but I’m intrigued by the no-sand approach. Does anyone know if chalk paint is as durable as milk paint over time? I’m concerned about wear and tear on furniture pieces.
2 Likes
@GreenThumb88, thanks for sharing your experience! The additives in chalk paint are definitely something to consider. I’ve been researching natural sealers that could maintain the eco-credentials of the project. Have you tried any natural waxes or oils for sealing your chalk-painted furniture?
1 Like
I’ve experimented with both chalk paint and milk paint, and each has its place. Chalk paint is fantastic for quick projects and achieving a modern matte look, while milk paint is my go-to for a more traditional, chippy finish. In terms of environmental footprint, I think it’s important to consider the entire lifecycle of the product, from production to disposal. Both have their pros and cons, but I lean towards milk paint for its simpler ingredient list.
4 Likes
@SandyShorelines, in my experience, chalk paint holds up pretty well, especially if you seal it properly. I’ve used a natural beeswax polish, which not only protects the paint but also enhances the color. It’s a bit more work, but worth it for the durability and eco-friendliness.
2 Likes
Has anyone tried mixing their own chalk paint at home? I’ve seen some recipes online using plaster of Paris and water-based paint. It seems like a more sustainable option, but I’m curious about the quality and durability compared to store-bought brands like Annie Sloan.
1 Like
@LeafyDreams, I’ve tried making my own chalk paint, and while it’s a fun project, I found the consistency and coverage to be hit or miss. It’s definitely a more sustainable option if you can get the mix right. Maybe we could share recipes and tips in a separate thread?
3 Likes
I’ve used both chalk paint and milk paint, and honestly, the durability really depends on the piece and how much wear it gets. Chalk paint is super easy to apply, but I’ve noticed it can chip if not sealed properly. Milk paint, though, once it’s on and sealed, it’s like it becomes part of the furniture. Tough as nails. But yeah, that prep work is a pain.
1 Like
Chalk paint’s no-sand approach is a lifesaver for me. I’m all about saving time and effort. But I get the concern about durability. I’ve found that using a good quality wax or a polycrylic sealer can really help protect the finish. It’s not 100% eco-friendly, but it’s a compromise I’m willing to make for the longevity of the piece.
3 Likes
I’m team milk paint all the way for that authentic look, but I’ve been curious about chalk paint too. The environmental aspect is a big deal for me. I’ve heard some chalk paints have synthetic additives, which kind of defeats the purpose of going eco-friendly. Does anyone know of a chalk paint brand that’s more natural?
2 Likes
The debate between chalk and milk paint is interesting. I lean towards chalk paint for furniture because of the ease of use and the modern matte finish it gives. But I do worry about the environmental impact. I’ve started looking into natural sealers like beeswax or linseed oil to keep it green. Has anyone tried these with chalk paint? How did it turn out?
2 Likes
I’ve actually tried making my own chalk paint at home using plaster of Paris and a basic water-based paint. It was a fun experiment, and I liked the idea of controlling the ingredients for a more eco-friendly option. The finish was pretty similar to store-bought brands, but I did notice it wasn’t as durable. After a few months, I saw some chips and wear that I hadn’t experienced with Annie Sloan’s. Still, for smaller projects or pieces that don’t get heavy use, it’s a decent alternative.
5 Likes
Mixing your own chalk paint sounds intriguing, but I’m a bit skeptical about the durability and consistency. I’ve had great results with Annie Sloan’s, especially on furniture that gets a lot of use. The no-prep aspect is a huge plus for me. Maybe if you’re doing a piece that’s more decorative than functional, DIY chalk paint could work. But for everyday furniture, I’d stick with the tried and true brands.
3 Likes
I’ve gone the DIY route with chalk paint too, and while it’s more sustainable, I found the texture can be hit or miss. Sometimes it’s perfect, other times it’s too thick or too runny. It definitely takes some trial and error. For sealing, I’ve used beeswax, which is natural and gives a nice finish, but it does require more maintenance than some of the synthetic sealers out there. It’s all about finding the right balance for your project and your eco-goals.
3 Likes
Interesting discussion! I haven’t tried making my own chalk paint yet, but I’m curious about the environmental impact of the additives in commercial chalk paints versus the DIY version. Does anyone know if the homemade version is significantly better for the environment, considering the plaster of Paris and the type of water-based paint used? Also, how does the cost compare? I’m all for sustainability, but if it’s going to break the bank, I might have to stick with store-bought for now.