Hey fellow green living enthusiasts! 
I’ve been diving deep into the world of natural paints for my latest home renovation project. After experimenting with a few store-bought eco-friendly options like Earth Pigments and The Real Milk Paint Co., I’m curious about taking it a step further by mixing my own plant-based paint. I’ve read about using ingredients like clay, chalk, and even plant dyes, but I’m a bit nervous about getting the consistency and durability right.
Has anyone here tried their hand at creating their own natural paint? I’m particularly interested in how it worked on different surfaces. Did you find it adhered well to walls, or was it better suited for furniture? Also, how did you handle the color mixing process? I’m dreaming of a soft, earthy palette for my living room but want to make sure it’s achievable with natural ingredients.
Lastly, for those who’ve gone the DIY route, were there any unexpected challenges or benefits? I’m all for reducing my environmental footprint, but I also want to ensure the end result is something I’ll love living with. Looking forward to hearing your experiences and tips!
I’ve experimented with making my own plant-based paint using clay and natural pigments. It’s a bit of a trial and error process, but the results can be stunning. I found that adding a bit of natural binder like linseed oil helped with the durability on walls. For furniture, I used beeswax as a finish, which gave it a lovely, soft sheen. Color mixing is definitely an art form; I recommend starting with small batches to test your palette.
3 Likes
@GreenThumb88 Thanks for sharing your experience! The tip about using linseed oil is really helpful. Did you find that the color changed much as it dried? I’m a bit nervous about getting the shades just right.
1 Like
@EcoPainterJane Yes, the color does change slightly as it dries, usually becoming a bit lighter. I found that doing a test patch and letting it dry completely before committing to a large area was the best approach. It’s all part of the fun of working with natural materials!
2 Likes
I tried making my own paint with chalk and plant dyes for a small project. It was a bit messy, but the colors were so vibrant! However, I did notice that it didn’t adhere as well to smoother surfaces. Maybe adding a primer or using a different binder could help with that?
4 Likes
@NatureLover101 Vibrant colors sound amazing! Did you use any specific plant dyes that you’d recommend? Also, did you find a way to improve the adhesion on smoother surfaces?
1 Like
@EcoPainterJane I used beetroot for a deep pink and turmeric for a bright yellow. They were surprisingly effective! As for adhesion, I haven’t tried it yet, but I’ve heard that casein (milk protein) can be a good natural binder for smoother surfaces. Might be worth experimenting with!
3 Likes
Mixing your own paint is definitely a rewarding experience, but it’s not without its challenges. One thing I learned is the importance of the pigment to binder ratio. Too much pigment and the paint can become brittle; too little and it might not cover well. I’ve had the best results with a mix of clay and chalk, using linseed oil as a binder. It’s durable and has a beautiful matte finish.
5 Likes
@DIYMaster That’s really insightful! Do you have any tips for getting the pigment to binder ratio just right? It sounds like a delicate balance.
2 Likes
@EcoPainterJane It really is a bit of an art. I start with a 1:1 ratio and adjust from there. If the paint is too thick, I add more binder; if it’s too thin, more pigment. It’s all about testing and adjusting until you get the consistency you’re happy with. Patience is key!
4 Likes
I’ve dabbled in making my own plant-based paints too, and I agree about the vibrant colors! For smoother surfaces, I found that mixing in a bit of casein powder as a binder really helped with adhesion. It’s a bit of trial and error, but once you get the mix right, the results can be stunning. Have you experimented with any other binders or additives to improve the paint’s performance?
2 Likes
That’s interesting about the adhesion issues. I tried a similar project but used linseed oil as a binder, and it worked pretty well on both walls and furniture. The key for me was to apply a thin layer and let it dry completely before adding another. It took longer, but the finish was more durable. Have you considered the drying time as a factor in how well the paint adheres?
5 Likes
I’ve dabbled in making my own paint too, and I agree about the pigment to binder ratio being crucial. I used a mix of natural pigments I sourced locally and a casein binder. It worked surprisingly well on plaster walls, giving a really unique texture and depth to the color. The trickiest part was getting the consistency right for application with a brush versus a roller.
1 Like
That’s interesting about the casein binder. I went with a lime wash for my walls, which is super eco-friendly and has antimicrobial properties. The downside is the color options are more limited, and it took a few coats to get the coverage I wanted. But the finish is breathable and has a lovely, soft matte look.
1 Like
I tried using plant dyes for a mural in my kid’s room, and while the colors were vibrant, they faded much quicker than I expected. I think next time I’ll look into more stable natural pigments or maybe even mix in a bit of mica for some shimmer and added durability.
1 Like
Has anyone experimented with adding essential oils to their paint for fragrance? I thought it might be a nice touch, especially for furniture pieces, but I’m worried it might affect the paint’s adhesion or longevity.
2 Likes
I’ve heard about adding essential oils but haven’t tried it myself. I did add a bit of beeswax to my last batch of paint to give it a bit more water resistance, which worked great for an outdoor bench. It did make the paint a bit trickier to apply smoothly, though.
5 Likes
For those worried about durability, I found that finishing with a natural sealant like shellac or a plant-based varnish really helped protect the paint without compromising its eco-friendly qualities. It’s an extra step, but worth it for high-traffic areas or furniture.
1 Like