Hey fellow green living enthusiasts! 
I’ve been diving deep into the world of natural paints for my latest home renovation project, and I’ve narrowed it down to two options that seem to be the most eco-friendly: milk paint and clay paint. I’ve used Real Milk Paint Co.‘s milk paint in the past for a vintage dresser makeover, and I was blown away by its smooth application and the rich, matte finish it gave. On the other hand, I’ve been hearing a lot about Earth Pigments’ clay paint for walls, especially its breathability and how it regulates indoor humidity.
What’s fascinating to me is how both paints have their unique benefits. Milk paint is made from simple ingredients like milk protein, lime, and natural pigments, making it biodegradable and non-toxic. Clay paint, meanwhile, is praised for its minimal environmental impact during production and its ability to be recycled or composted after use. I’m curious about your experiences with these paints. Have you tried them on different surfaces? How did they hold up over time? And from an environmental standpoint, which one do you think takes the cake?
Let’s discuss! Have you found one to be more versatile or easier to work with than the other? Also, if you’ve experimented with any DIY recipes for either paint, I’d love to hear about your mix ratios and any tips you might have. Looking forward to your insights and stories! 
I’ve used both Real Milk Paint Co.‘s milk paint and Earth Pigments’ clay paint in my home, and I must say, each has its place. Milk paint is fantastic for furniture because of its durability and the unique finish it provides. However, for walls, I lean towards clay paint. Its ability to regulate humidity is a game-changer, especially in bathrooms and kitchens. From an eco-friendly perspective, both are excellent choices, but clay paint edges out slightly due to its lower environmental impact during production.
3 Likes
@GreenThumb88 Thanks for sharing your experience! I hadn’t considered the humidity regulation aspect of clay paint for specific rooms. That’s a great point. Did you find any difference in the application process between the two?
1 Like
@EcoPainterJane Absolutely! Milk paint requires a bit more prep work, especially if you’re going for that chippy, vintage look. You need to apply a bonding agent on non-porous surfaces. Clay paint, on the other hand, is more forgiving and easier to apply directly to walls. It’s also easier to touch up if needed.
2 Likes
I’m all about minimizing waste, so I tried making my own milk paint using a DIY recipe I found online. It was a fun project! I used milk protein, lime, and natural pigments. The color wasn’t as vibrant as store-bought, but it was rewarding to use something I made myself. Has anyone else tried DIY recipes for either paint?
4 Likes
@NatureLover101 That sounds amazing! I’ve been curious about DIY paint recipes. Could you share the mix ratios you used? I’d love to give it a try on a small project.
1 Like
@CraftySoul Sure! I used 1 part milk protein, 1 part lime, and then added natural pigments until I got the desired shade. It’s a bit of trial and error, but start with small amounts and adjust as you go. Good luck, and let me know how it turns out!
2 Likes
I’ve been using Earth Pigments’ clay paint for a while now, and I’m impressed with its performance. Not only is it eco-friendly, but it also has a unique texture that adds depth to walls. I recently painted my living room, and the difference in air quality is noticeable. It’s like the walls are breathing! For anyone considering clay paint, I highly recommend giving it a try.
5 Likes
@SustainableSam That’s exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for! The idea of walls ‘breathing’ is fascinating. Did you encounter any challenges with the application, or was it straightforward?
1 Like
@EcoPainterJane The application was surprisingly easy. The paint has a nice consistency that spreads well without dripping. The only tip I’d give is to make sure your walls are properly prepped. Clay paint is quite forgiving, but starting with a smooth, clean surface makes all the difference.
1 Like
I’ve been using milk paint for a while now, mostly on furniture, and I love the vintage look it gives. But I’ve been curious about clay paint for walls, especially after hearing about its humidity regulation. Does it really make a noticeable difference in rooms like the bathroom? I’m considering giving it a try for my next project.
5 Likes
Clay paint’s humidity regulation is a big plus, especially in areas prone to moisture. I used it in my kitchen and noticed a significant improvement in air quality. However, I found it a bit challenging to apply evenly compared to milk paint. Any tips on application would be appreciated!
5 Likes
I think the choice between milk and clay paint really depends on the project. For furniture, milk paint is unbeatable for that authentic, aged look. But for walls, especially in damp areas, clay paint’s benefits are hard to ignore. I’m curious, has anyone tried mixing both for a project? Wondering if that could combine the best of both worlds.
5 Likes
That’s awesome you tried making your own milk paint! I’ve been curious about DIY paint recipes but haven’t taken the plunge yet. How did you find the consistency compared to the Real Milk Paint Co.'s version? I imagine getting it just right could be tricky.
3 Likes
I’ve dabbled with both milk and clay paints, and while I love the eco-friendly aspect, I found clay paint to be a bit more forgiving on walls, especially in high-traffic areas. It seems to hold up better over time. But for furniture, milk paint is my go-to for that authentic vintage look.
3 Likes
DIY paint projects sound fun, but I worry about the durability. Has anyone had issues with their homemade paint peeling or fading faster than store-bought options? I’d love to try it if it can last.
I tried making clay paint once, following a recipe that used natural clay, chalk, and a binder. The texture was interesting, and it applied well, but I struggled with getting the color intensity I wanted. Maybe I needed to add more pigment?
For those who’ve experimented with both, how do you find the cleanup process compares between milk and clay paints? I’ve heard milk paint can be a bit messier to work with and clean up after.
5 Likes
I’m intrigued by the idea of making my own paint, especially to customize colors. Does anyone have tips for sourcing natural pigments? I’d love to try creating a palette that matches my home’s aesthetic perfectly.
4 Likes
I’ve been on the milk paint train for a couple of years now, and honestly, it’s been a game-changer for my furniture projects. The finish is just unbeatable, and knowing it’s all natural gives me peace of mind. But I’m curious about this clay paint for walls. Does it really help with air quality? I might have to give it a shot in my bedroom.
4 Likes